Betterbird Blog

What’s going on in the project

Thunderbird spin doctors at work: 153 supposedly more stable than 140 - No!

- Posted in Ranting by

In her latest post to the Thunderbird Planning mailing list Thunderbird chief propagandist Kelly McSweeney wrote (quote):

ESR rollout in review: There are far less significant issues this year thanks to a full year of monthly release and excellent coverage/response from the team.

Well, we don't know what is classified as significant, but the numbers speak a different language.

There were 56 bugs in relation to the deployment of Thunderbird 140 ESR, see this meta bug, but there are 189 bugs related to the 153 ESR deployment, see here.

While these statistics aren't very accurate, a significant increase is visible. There are still regressions unfixed in 153.5.0 ESR, even months after the initial release of the 153 series, for example a broken UI as reported here and here.

BTW, Kelly uses Google webmail to create those reports, since Thunderbird is apparently such a horrible product, see the user agent detection here:

Gmail user agent detection